Editors’ Note: This article is a continuation of City on a Hill Press’ coverage published throughout the 2025-26 school year regarding Family Student Housing. Some of the same sources were interviewed to follow updates surrounding this issue.
Andrew Allio, a history PhD candidate and Family Student Housing (FSH) resident since 2021, recently moved from the original FSH complex on Heller Drive to the new complex on Hagar Drive. Although apartments in the new complex now include updated appliances, such as a dishwasher, washer and dryer, these upgrades come at a cost: a nearly $600 rent increase.
There are 79 fewer units available compared to the old FSH complex, bringing the total number of units down from 199 to 120.
Families began moving to the new complex shortly before the start of fall quarter, but have already encountered obstacles in terms of the quality of the new units. Allio said that he has called maintenance frequently, seemingly every other day.
“Just this morning, some of the flooring is a little bit warped. Our toilet wasn’t working the day we moved in. There’s all these minor little things breaking into the house that haven’t really been addressed,” he said.
Many families’ stagnant status on the waitlist has left them to face Santa Cruz’s competitive housing market. With constant timeline pushbacks, residents are left wondering why struggling families could not have been in the old complex this entire time, instead of remaining empty or as furniture storage.
Across the parking lot of the newly built complexes sits a fenced-off construction site for several unfinished units in the Hagar Drive FSH complex.
The window of a finished complex reflects nearby construction.
New Complex, Faulty Windows
The move-in timeline was initially delayed six months last spring due to incorrectly sized windows in the new complex. Once families moved into the new complex, they found the 36-inch-tall windows with the lever at the bottom to be ADA accessible, but failed to implement any sort of safety feature or screen.
“These are the second windows that have gone in, and they still didn’t pick up on the fact that this was a life hazard for children,” said Melissa Mack, a sixth-year literature PhD candidate and FSH resident of five years. “People started circulating pictures and videos that our windows open very widely, there’s no screens and no limiters on how far they open. A child or anyone with mobility concerns could easily fall out the window.”
Scott Hernandez-Jason, associate vice chancellor of communications and marketing, clarified the use of the windows in an email to City on a Hill Press.
“The Hagar residential buildings were designed to meet applicable California Building Code requirements, including requirements for emergency egress from bedrooms,” he wrote. “These particular windows are intended for emergency egress rather than regular usage. Following feedback from residents about how the emergency egress windows function in a family residential environment, our facilities and project teams immediately reviewed options for additional modifications.”
He continued, “Interim limiting devices have now been installed, beginning with second-floor units, and the windows were labeled for emergency egress. Our project and facilities teams are evaluating longer-term options that address resident concerns while continuing to meet applicable building and egress requirements.”
Once the administration became aware of these hazards, within three days, stick-on limiters had been installed along with stickers reading “Emergency Escape Window.” The limiters are stuck on either side of the window, with the window still swinging open if the implement is disconnected. 
An “EMERGENCY ESCAPE WINDOW” sticker is placed on most of the windows that sit a few feet off the ground.
Directly outside the screenless windows are HVAC units connected to the complex.
Hernandez-Jason assured City on a Hill Press that these are temporary implementations, with more permanent solutions to come.
“This whole time we’ve been asking for more transparency. It’s like pulling teeth. It always goes back to uncertainty,” said Alex Stokes, a fourth-year education PhD candidate and FSH resident of four-and-a-half years.
Old Complex Conditions
Residents still living in the old complex have had to endure the buildings’ deterioration, with the university exhibiting no sign of intervention efforts. Although they were originally built in the 1970s, the buildings have not had many upgrades since its initial opening, resulting in its general run-down environment.
“It’s just a shame they built these places not that long [ago] but have done nothing to maintain them or keep them up,” said Hannah Newburn, a literature PhD candidate and FSH resident. “If they’d kept these places up they wouldn’t have to be doing this whole tear down rebuild. It seems like a kind of crazy waste of resources.”
Newburn moved into FSH five years ago, after the birth of her son. However, her residency has been littered with struggles.
“My five-year-old was hospitalized last year with pneumonia and has since been going to a pulmonologist … because certain kinds of allergenic asthma are exacerbated by mold and humidity,” Newburn said. “He had pneumonia three times that year.”
According to Newburn, the physician specializing in respiratory treatment her son was referred to frequently treats patients of all ages who live in FSH. 
In front of the electrical room are skateboards and a bike owned by residents of the new Hagar Drive FSH complex.
A child’s play car is left in front of the Main Distribution Frame room.
After her son’s hospitalization, which occurred on Christmas Day, Newburn demanded the removal of the carpeting in her family’s apartment. Similarly, the temperature conditions due to lack of building insulation make it nearly unbearable for daily living.
“We deal with extreme heat in the summer. On your average 75-degree day, in my house it’ll be like 90 degrees upstairs,” Newburn said.
To begin a conversation with the university regarding unfair price charges and poor housing conditions, FSH residents organized the FSH Tenants Association, consisting of residents advocating for the rights and concerns of students and their families.
In February 2025, the FSH Tenants Association negotiated to freeze the rent increase. Everyone, regardless of new or old complex residents, is currently paying the same rent until all families have moved to the new complex, estimated by the end of December 2026. Another win by the FSH Tenants Association was providing a $2,500 rent credit, equal to one month’s rent, to support residents dealing with moving costs. Once the transition is completed, the rent freeze will cease and the rent credit will be applied.
Vacancy Trade-Off
Former resident Nate Edenhofer’s apartment in the old complex is surrounded by vacant units — the unit above, the one to the left, and the one to the right are all empty.
“Even if it was a one-year contract, there’s a hundred units that people could be living in for one year. Instead, they send people to hotels or things like that, or people just don’t have a place [to live],” he said.
Additionally, the university would not be able to guarantee those tenants a space in the new FSH due to the 80-unit cutback. Tenants also wonder if the poor conditions are due to possible plans of demolition that have yet to be confirmed by the UC administration.
“They still have the gall to charge that person so much money for the security deposit knowing that they’re gonna tear these [buildings] down and not put any real effort into rehabilitating them,” Edenhofer continued.
An alum who has since moved out of the old complex shared a contract cancellation confirmation email from the FSH office sent on Oct. 21 with City on a Hill Press. The message states: “Following these instructions will: Allow [the university] to have the apartment ready for a new resident promptly in order to help alleviate the housing crisis many student families are experiencing.”
According to pages 4-5 of the FSH housing contract, “Students will receive written notice of their reassignment to the new Family Student Housing facility at least 60 days prior to being required to move.”
However, the university disregarded the 60-day notice as residents prepare to move into the new FSH complex with a Dec.15 move-in date.
“The reality is that everyone would benefit from 60 days’ notice. Just because people are anxious and eager to move doesn’t mean that they wouldn’t benefit from that 60 days’ notice,” Alex Stokes said. “Our four-year-old is asking when we’re going to move and what she can bring with her to the move. We’re doing our best to answer those questions, but it takes a toll on everyone.”
Due to the university prioritizing moving families with children, those without, such as Melissa Mack and her husband, would have to take a backseat.
“The whole message that I’m getting is [UCSC] actually do[es]n’t want student families,” Mack said. “That really makes me sad, because families are an amazing part of a university community and people who are inside of developed family structures of any kind have just as many amazing contributions to make to a university community as anybody else.”